GSW: 1958 MEETING MINUTES

 

GEOLOGICAL  SOCIETY  OF  WASHINGTON

Secretary's Report

January 8, 1958

The 782nd meeting of the Society was held in the Assembly Hall of the Cosmos Club, Wednesday evening, January 8, at 8:00 p.m., President Carle H. Dane presiding.

The minutes of the 781st meeting were read and approved.

The election to active membership of B. Carter Hearn of the Geological Survey was announced.

The Council decision to continue the past practice of cash awards for the best papers was announced.

The President announced the deaths of two members, George H. Garrey and Louis M. Prindle.

It was revealed that the Council decided not to attempt an enumeration of our vice-presidents this year in the customary, coin-flipping manner, so that in the event of the loss of "our revered president" the Society would be faced with this difficult task.

The action of the Council in approving, ex post facto, the further deferment of last year's Presidential address to "sometime next fall" was announced. Our incumbent President candidly expressed his hope that this custom might be continued until he had had an opportunity to get out of town.

The report of an ad hic committee appointed by the President to study the perennial beer problem, raised at the last Annual Meeting and from time to time previously, was read by Mr. Kinney, Chairman. Other members were Duncan and Pecora. Pecora, who professed to know nothing of the work of this committee, complimented the committee on a fine report.

J. B. Mertie, Jr., read an informal communication entitled "A monazite lode in South Africa."

The regular program followed:

Harry Klemic, A. V, Heyl, A. R. Taylor, and Jerome Stone-- Rare earth deposit at the Scrub Oaks mine, Morris County, New Jersey.  Discussed by Johnston, Murata, Paul, and Milton.

Isidore Zietz, G. E. Andreasen and Arthur Grantz — Aeromagnetic study of Cook Inlet, Alaska.  Discussed by Paul, Dutro, and Dempsey.

Attendance: 90

The meeting adjourned at 9:32 p.m.

Philip W. Guild

Secretary

 

GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

Secretary’s Report

January 22, 1958

The 783rd meeting of the Society was held in the Assembly Hall of the Cosmos Club, Wednesday evening, January 22, at 8:00 p.m., President Carle H. Dane presiding.

The minutes of the 782d meeting were read and approved.

The election to active membership of the following was announced: Richard J. Meinert, Jr., Corps of Engineers, U. S. Army; Henry Bell III, U. S. Geological Survey; Grace C. Keroher, U. S. Geological Survey; Sandra Whalen, U. S. Geological Survey.

Messrs. Stewart, Rubin, Friedman, Murata, Paul and Adler very informally communicated to the Society the sighting, at 7:22 p.m. (barely 45 minutes previously), of Sputnik II.  In spite of various discrepancies in their stories, possibly caused by the rigorous conditioning undergone by most members of the expedition, there was general agreement that credit for the discovery belonged to Meyer Rubin, who was looking in the wrong place. Mason commented that, inasmuch as the satellite passed directly overhead, Rubin was obviously flat on his back.

Ellis Yochelson reviewed and recommended a recently translated science fiction book by a Russian vertebrate paleontologist.

Robert C. Stephenson announced three new publications of the American Geological Institute:

Directory of Geologic Materials in North America

Earth for the Layman

Shall I study geological sciences?

The last named was recommended by the speaker to those in the audience that might be interested in making a career of geology.

The regular program followed:

D. M. Kinney, W. J. Hail, Jr., and A. D. Zapp--Latest Cretaceous and earliest Tertiary rocks between Castlegate and Green River, Utah.

W. L. Newman, A. T. Miesch, and E. M. Shoemaker--Chemical composition as a guide to the size of sandstone type uranium deposits, Colorado Plateau.  Discussed by Friedman, Fleischer, Murata, Byerly, and Mason.

Charles Milton, Mary E. Mrose, and E. C. T. Chao--Recent developments on the mineralogy of the Green River shale. Discussed by Mason. Dane, and Fleischer.

Attendance: 108.

The meeting adjourned at 9:50 p.m.

Philip W. Guild

Secretary

 

GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

Secretary s Report

February 12, 1958

The 784th meeting of the Society was held in the Assembly Hall of the Cosmos Club, Wednesday evening, February 12, at 8:00 p.m., President Carle L Dane presiding.

The minutes of the 783d meeting were read and approved.

The Secretary announced the election to active membership of J. Bruce Fisher, Bureau of Ships, Department of the Navy.

The President informed the Society of the death of Fred H. Moffit.

An informal communication by Pres Cloud on the mode of locomotion of upper Cambrian trilobites failed to convince all members present, although "it seemed perfectly obvious to the speaker” that they moved sideways.

The regular program followed:

Ralph L. Miller--Faulting in the southern Appalachians.

David M. Raup--The effect of environment on echinoid morphology.  Discussed by Peck, Cloud, Abelson, Wagner, Stewart, Sohn, and Lovering.

Brig. R. A. Bagnold--Correlation between wind and sand dune directions in the light of present day conditions. Discussed by Johnston, Neuman, Gilluly, and Leopold.

Attendance: 158.

The meeting adjourned at 9:44 p.m.

Philip W. Guild

Secretary

 

GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

Secretary s Report

February 26, 1958

The 785th meeting of the Society was held in the Assembly Hall of the Cosmos Club, Wednesday evening, February 26, at 8:00 p.m., Vice-President Lloyd G. Henbest presiding.

The minutes of the 784th meeting were read and approved.

The Secretary announced the election to active membership of the following: Paul E. Klopsteg, National Science Foundation; Harris B. Stewart, Coast and Geodetic Survey; Clyde S. Conover, U. S. Geological Survey; John E. Johnston, U. S. Geological Survey; Elmer D. Patterson, U. S. Geological Survey.

Announcement was made of a TV program on crystals to be given by Ed Roedder at 8:00 a.m. on March 15­.

Vice-President Henbest introduced Dr. Camacho of Argentina to the Society.

An informal communication by Wendell Woodring on specialization of geologic terminology as exemplified by a passage from a recent petrologic paper on California eclogites gave rise to a warning by Bill Rubey that “a shy person” would retaliate at an early date.

Henry Faul showed by means of a press dispatch from Moscow that even the Russians are not free of pseudoscientific nonsense emanating from sources that should know better.

Pres Cloud returned to the fray with a sequel to his effort of the previous meeting. Several objections were raised by members of the Geochem­istry and Petrology Branch, and we may yet have a "trilobite trilogy" if Pres persists.

The regular program followed:

John C. Reed., Jr.--Crystalline rocks of the Potomac River Gorge near Washington, D. C. Discussed by Woodring, Mason, Pecora, Milton, Thayer, and Murata.

F. G. Houtermans--Effects of cosmic radiation in meteorites and the Earth's atmosphere. Discussed by Tilton, Roedder, Pecora, Faul, and Rubin.

Attendance: 132

The meeting adjourned at 9:48 p.m.

Philip W. Guild

Secretary.

 

GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

Secretary's Report

March 12, 1958

The 786th meeting of the Society was held in the Assembly Hall of the Cosmos Club, Wednesday evening, March 12, at 8:00 p.m., President Carle H. Dane presiding.

The minutes of the 785th meeting were read and approved, with a small correction by a shy person.

The Secretary announced the election to active membership of the following:

John M. Good, National Park Service; John H. Adamson, Erwin S. Asselstine, Henry C. Barksdale, Albert N. Cameron, Charles W. Carlston, Dagfin J. Cederstrom   , Warren W. Hastings, Water Resources Division, U. S. Geological Survey; Helen L. Foster, Military Geology Branch, U. S. Geological Survey; Gordon H. Wood, Junius A. Van Lieu, Kenneth J. Englund, Fuels Branch, U. S. Geological Survey.

A Memorial to Fred H. Moffit was presented by John B. Mertie.

The regular program followed:

U. S. Geological Survey investigations at the Nevada test site.­

E. B. Eckel and C. B. Read--Geological phase.      

W. H. Diment and Others--Geophysical phase. Discussed by Wetherill, Dane, James, Smith, Ernst, Morey, Thayer, and Guild.

Attendance: 175

The meeting adjourned at 9:30 p.m.

P. W. Guild

Secretary

 

GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

Secretary's Report

March 26, 1958

The 787th meeting of the Society was held in the Assembly Hall of the Cosmos, Wednesday evening, March 26, at 8:00 p.m., President Carle H. Dane presiding.

The minutes of the 786th meeting were read and approved.

The Secretary announced the election to membership of the following: Raymond S. Shrode, Geologist, B&O Railroad; John Guy Ferris, Brian J. Skinner, Benjamin Weiss, U. S. Geological Survey.

The regular program followed:

M. Gordon Wolman and Lucien M. Brush, Jr. (presented by Mr. Brush) - ­Laboratory study of equilibrium channel shape in noncohesive material.  Discussed by Cloud, Pecora, McGuinness, Dane, Peck, and Faul.

J. T. Hack--The relation of manganese to surficial deposits in the Shenandoah Valley, Virginia.  Discussed by Wolman, Stephenson, Pavlides, Smith, Pecora, White, Cloud, Murata, McGuinness, and Guild.

Earl Ingerson--The Moscow symposium on petrochemistry, December 1957.  Discussed by James, Thayer, Joesting, Johnston, Wolman, Stephenson, Poire, Pecora, Stadnichenko, and Faul.

Attendance: 114.

The meeting adjourned at 9:45 p.m.

P. W. Guild

Secretary

 

GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

Secretary's Report

April 9, 1958

The 788th meeting of the Society was held in the John Wesley Powell Audito­rium of the Cosmos Club, Wednesday evening, April 9, at 8:00 p.m., President Carle H. Dane presiding.

The minutes of the 787th meeting were read and approved.

The President announced that the Society has contributed $125 to the Joint Board on Science Education in the Greater Washington Area, which among other things promotes and supports the Science Fairs. Ed Roedder has been appointed to act as a judge of exhibits in the field of Earth Sciences on April 19.

There were no informal communications.

The regular program followed:

G. W. Wetherill, G. R. Tilton and G. L. Davis--Age of the Baltimore gneiss.  Discussed by Mertie, Cloos, Thayer, Gottfried, Hopson, and Waters.

David Landen--New developments in photogrammetric measurements for geologists. Discussed by Friedman.

Vincent C. Kelley--Structure and fracture systems of the Colorado Plateau.  Discussed by Dane.

Attendance: 120.

The meeting adjourned at 9:52 p.m.

P. W. Guild

Secretary

 

GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

Secretary's Report

April 23, 1958

The 789th meeting of the Society was held in the John Wesley Powell Auditorium of the Cosmos Club, Wednesday evening, April 23, at 8:00 p.m., President Carle H. Dane presiding.

The minutes of the 788th meeting were read and approved.

The Secretary announced the election to membership of Lester H. Durloo Jr., U. S.Army, Corps of Engineers.

The President informed the Society that the Council is investigating various plans for making group rates on major medical and income maintenance insurance available to the members. A definite proposal will be presented in the fall.

Ed Roedder reported on the Science Fair held in Georgetown April 19, announcing the winners in the Earth Science division and introducing Philip Perkins, winner of the 12th grade prize for a paleontological exhibit of reptiles and mammals.

L. T. Aldrich informally communicated the seismic detection in the Washington area and New York state of the Ripple Rock blast in the Seymour Narrows, British Columbia.

The regular program followed:

Gordon E. Andreasen, Isidore Zietz and Arthur Grantz--Structural interpretation of aeromagnetic data observed in the Copper River Basin, Alaska, presented by Mr. Andreasen.

Z. S. Altschuler and E. J. Young--Relations between Tertiary sedi­mentation and structural history in west central Florida, presented by Mr. Altschuler.

Richard H. Jahns and C. Wayne Burnham--Preliminary experimental evidence on pegmatite crystallization, presented by Dr. Jahns.  Discussed by Orville, Stewart, Friedman, Roedder, Thurston, Fleischer, and Johnston.

Attendance: 122

The meeting adjourned at 9:50 p.m.

P. W. Guild

Secretary

 

GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

Secretary's Report

October 8, 1958

The 790th meeting of the Society was held in the John Wesley Powell Auditorium, Wednesday evening, Oct. 8, at 8:00 p.m., President Carle H. Dane presiding.

The minutes of the 789th meeting were read and approved after some comment on and explanation of the new name of our meeting place.

The Secretary announced the election to membership of the following: Paul B. Whitney Oil & Gas Division, Dept. of Interior; Glenn F. Brown, Richmond F. Brown, Rodney Hart, Roy O. Jackson, Robert W. Maclay, Carol N. Metcalf, A. E. Peckham, Frances G. Thompson, Eugene S. Simpson, Water Resources Division, U. S. G. S.; Marion J. Bergin, George W. Colton, Wallace deWitt, Jr., Leonard D. Harris, John W. Huddle, Henry L. Smith, Robert J. Trevethan, Arthur C. Meisinger, Fuels Branch, U. S. Geological Survey;

Peter Toulmin, G&P Branch, U. S. Geological Survey.

The Secretary announced that at a Special Meeting of the Council on July 11, 1958, C. L. McGuinness was elected to the Council to replace ­Hal James, and Sergius Mamay to replace Fred Cater.

The President informed the Society of the death of John B. Reeside.

Announcement was made by the President of the Council's decision to make available to the members of the Society a program of group health insurance. The investigations leading up to this decision were reviewed; the major features of the plan were outlined briefly; and eligibility to participate was defined. The active members, numbering 439, will be circularized by the insurance agent in the near future; it is believed that corresponding members will be given an opportunity to participate somewhat later. The President invited questions on this program from the floor, but apparently had satisfied any existing curiosity as no discussion was forthcoming.

There were no informal communications.

The regular program followed:

The deferred presidential address of W. D. Johnston, Jr.--Outside Interior or the Geological Survey's part in foreign technical assistance, 1940-1958.

Attendance: 124.

The meeting adjourned at 9:30 p. m.

P. W. Guild

Secretary

 

GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

Secretary's Report

October 22, 1958

The 791st meeting of the Society was held in the John Wesley Powell Auditorium, Wednesday evening, October 22, at 8:00 p.m., President Carle H.. Dane. presiding.

The minutes of the 790th meeting were read and approved.

The Secretary announced the election to membership of the following: William M. Briggs, Jr., P.&S. Branch, U.S.G.S.; Eleanor J. Crosby and Martha J. Toulmin, Geologic Names Committee, U.S.G.S.

The Secretary informed the Society that a few copies of the April issue of the Journal of the Washington Academy of Science, containing the proceedings for 1957, are still available. He also asked that all abstracts of talks presented this year be submitted by December 10.

The President introduced a visitor, Dr. Emily Yaeger of Bern, Switzerland.

There were no informal communications.

The regular meeting followed:

Adrian Richards--Eruption of Capelinhos Volcano, Faial Island, Azores, a report of the Cranbrook Expedition, 1958. Discussed by Johnston, Goldman, Gates, and an unidentified gentleman.

Irving Friedman--Deuterium and the age of Arctic sea ice. Discussed by White, Balsley, Thurston, Joesting, and Skinner.

D. Foster Hewett--Deposits of the manganese oxides. Dis­cussed by Gilluly, Johnston, and Fleischer.

Attendance: 160.

The meeting adjourned at 10:00 p.m.

P. W. Guild

Secretary

 

GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

Secretary's Report

November 12, 1958

The 792d meeting of the Society was held jointly with the Paleontological Society of Washington in the John Wesley Powell Auditorium, Wednesday evening, November 12, at 8:00 p.m., Vice-President Alice Allen presiding.

The minutes of the 791st meeting were read and approved.

The Secretary announced the election to membership of the following: James F. Tazelaar, Army Corps of Engineers; Dayle Baldauf, Engineering Department, U. S. Array; Philip F. Fix, Military Geology Branch, U.S.G.S.; Phyllis F. Foreman, Military Geology Branch, U.S.G.S.; Yetta Levinsky, Geologic Division, U.S.G.S.; William B. Roberts, III, Geologic Division, U.S.G.S.; Amos M. White, Mineral Deposits Branch, U.S.G.S.; William D. Long, G&P Branch, U.S.G.S.

There were no informal communications.

Vice-President Allen, after reviewing the history of joint meetings with the Paleontologists, introduced Ellis Yochelson, who in turn introduced the speaker, Alfred S. Romer.

Prof. Romer's talk, which commemorated the Darwin-Wallace Centennial, was entitled "Rocks, fossils, and Darwin." Discussion by Whitmore, Allen,. Woodring, and Burke evoked a fine rendition from the speaker of his theme song "It's a long way from Amphioxus"

Attendance: 178.

The meeting adjourned at 9:17 p.m.

P. W. Guild

Secretary

 

GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

Secretary's Report

December 10, 1958

The 793d meeting of the Society was. held in the John Wesley Powell Auditorium, Wednesday evening, December 10, at 8:00 p.m., Vice-President Lloyd Henbest presiding.

The minutes of the 792d meeting were read and approved.

The Secretary announced the election to membership of the following:

Francisco Antonio Parada, Geological Service of Columbia; Linn Hoover and Sophie Drakoulis, Fuels Branch, U.S.G.S.; Paul C. Bateman, Mary Lou Conant, James G. Moore, Donald W. Peterson, G. I. Smith, Mineral Deposits Branch, U.S.G.S. Menlo Park California; Graham Chinner, Werner F. Schreyer, Allan C. Turnock, David R. Wones, Geophysical Laboratories, 2801 Upton Street, N.W., Washington, D. C.; Robert W. Johnson, Geophysics Branch, U.S.G.S.; George B. Magin, Jr., Water Resources Branch, U.S.G.S.; Thelma Hill and Anne Hetzel, Geologic Division, U.S.G.S.; Joseph J. Tregoning, G&P Branch, U.S.G.S.; J. Alexander Heslin, Jr., John D. Glassaway, Celine W. Merrill, Ronny Hemmerick, Earl G. Hoover, Frank M. Giordano, Geology students, George Washington University.

The preparation of a new membership list, dated November 1, 1958, was announced. Copies are available upon request.

The Secretary read a communication from the AGI announcing a new pamphlet on "The member societies of the American Geological Institute."

There were no informal communications.

The Presidential address followed: Carle H. Dane--The New Mexico geologic map--a summary of 30 years of geologic progress.

Attendance: 138.

The meeting adjourned at 9:20 p.m.

P. W. Guild

Secretary

 

GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

66th Annual Meeting

December 10, 1958

The 66th Annual Meeting of the Society was held in the John Wesley Powell Auditorium, Wednesday evening, December 10, at 9:42 p.m., President Carle H. Dane presiding.

The minutes of the 65th Annual Meeting were read and approved.

The annual report of the Secretaries for 1958 was read and approved.

The annual report of the Treasurer was presented by Mary Mrose. After her experience of the previous year, Mary was a good Scout and came Prepared—­loaded for beer. A minutely detailed breakdown by keg, bottle, can, brand, and price revealed that Gunther cans were $5 a case.  A voice from the audience cried, "You can get it cheaper!"  To a request for "who recommended Valley Forge?" Mary replied "I just pay the bills."  As it turned out, the disbursements for the year exceeded receipts by $303.86, which was almost exactly the cost of the beer, $305.40.  The Treasurer announced that she has breakdowns on refreshments for all 14 meetings covered by her report and offered to present them.

The Auditing Committee, Bill Fischer, Chairman, and Mickey Carron report­ed that it had examined the Treasurer's accounts and found them "eminently correct.”  They confirmed that Mary does indeed have all 14 breakdowns.

The Treasurer's Report was unanimously and enthusiastically accepted. The President commended Mary for her three-year stint as Treasurer, and the members gave her a resounding ovation.

The report of the Awards Committee, consisting of J. T. Hack, Chairman, Henry Faul, John Eric, C. L. McGuinness, and Ellis Yochelson was presented by Henry Faul.  First prize of $20 was awarded to G. W. Wetherill, G. R. Tilton and G. L. Davis for their paper entitled "Age of the Baltimore gneiss."

Second prize of $10 was awarded to Isidore Zietz, G. E. Andreasen, and Arthur Grantz for their paper "Aeromagnetic study of Cook Inlet, Alaska."

The Sleeping Bear cup was awarded by Pres Cloud, Chairman of the Com­mittee which also included Gus Bozion and Josh Tracey.  Pres reviewed the criteria for eligibility for this award, "presented for informal, even disorganized discussion."  He recollected that James had, the year before, made amateur standing a prime requisite, "thereby eliminating Pecora, Woodring, Hunt, and others of this ilk."  James had included discussion made from either a standing or sitting position, before, during, or after the talk, to the speaker or as an aside. Cloud went even further, extend­ing the criteria of eligibility to "uttered or unuttered, or simply muttered, before or after, immediately after and much after the meeting, at the back of the hall, in the Cosmos Club, or at Fergies, etc."  He discussed three obvious choices--himself, the G&P team on satellite sighting, and "our beloved Director, whose unuttered comments have been both informative and revealing." His Committee would not go along on first choice, the G&P group was ruled out as an obvious attempt on Pecora's part to get around the loss of his amateur standing, and the Director was ruled out because of the top of grade and pay raise adjustments.  This apparently left no candidates and an awkward situation--should the Committee make no award or lower the standards? Upon reflection, a fourth candidate was discovered, one who had by a simple remark, "not to me it isn't," effectively stopped an effort

by Pres himself to convince the members that the evidence for trilobite tracks and hence their mode of locomotion, was "clear, conclusive, and obvious."  The recipient, Bill Bradley, said simply "I am speechless."

The President announced that no amendments to the Constitution had been submitted to the Council.  He then reported that the insurance plan was now in force and introduced Mr. Bremsteller to the Society.  Bremsteller spoke briefly.

The President then called for any other new business. Yochelson urged that the Society take an active part in educating the public on Earth Science and suggested formation of a Committee on Public Service. This was referred to the new Council for consideration.

Sohn's motion that the Society shift to a Fiscal Year so that the Annual Meeting would come at a warmer time was ruled out of order as an amendment to the Constitution.

The Society then passed to election of officers for 1959.  The President explained that a single slate had been presented, and that no other candidates had been proposed by petition to the Council, as provided for in the By-Laws. He asked if there were any nominations from the floor. There being none, it was moved, seconded, and passed that the Secretary be instructed to cast a unanimous ballot for the officers nominated by the committee.

The following officers and councilors were elected:

President: Joseph W. Greig

1st Vice-President: Charles A. Anderson

2d Vice-President: Louis C. Conant

Secretary: J. Thomas Dutro

Treasurer: Helen Weissenborn

Members at large of the Council (2-year terms) -­ Charles S. Denny, John E. Johnson, Robert C. Stephenson

Vice-President, Washington Academy of Science -Carle H. Dane

Attendance: 106

The meeting adjourned at 10:33 p.m.

P. W Guild

Secretary