GSW: 1993 MEETING MINUTES

 

MINUTES OF THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

1233rd Meeting, January 13,  1993

     President Bethke called the meeting to order at 8:04 p.m.

     Sixteen visitors were introduced: Andrea Ray, Jane Scherer, David Stanberg, Peter Schultz, Glenda Newell, Noritake Nishide, Allan Linde, Francois Schweizer, Gregory Walsh, Athene Walsh, Kevin Crowley, Ray Parker, Linda Freeman, Jodie Bougois, and two graduate students from George Washington University whose names I didn't get.  Two new members were announced: Bruce Molnia and Alexander Ross; we were also notified of the death of member Ed McKnight.  President Bethke announced a joint meeting with the Potomac Geophysical Society to be held on March 18, and the cancellation of the previously scheduled meeting of March 24.  There were no informal communications.

     William Ruddiman of the University of Virginia started the program with a lecture on "The role of plateau uplift in climate change."  Bill reviewed conventional mechanisms for climate change such as volcanism, orography sealevel fluctuations, seafloor spreading, and orbital variations, and proposed a new model involving large, high-altitude plateaus.   His model uses evidence for major cooling of the Earth over the past 40 million years, and a suggested relationship to the Tibetan plateau, which has undergone major uplift during the same 40 million years.   Plateaus are considered important because of their large surface area and elevation that dramatically change atmospheric circulation patterns.  Uplift of plateaus also creates fresh rock and increased topographic relief that produce more physical weathering and eventual removal of CO2 from the hydrosphere. This talk was a tidy 20 minutes long. Questions by Malcolm Ross, Paul Silber, Meyer Rubin, Jodie Bougois, Karen Prestegaard, and Patrick Taylor.

     Christopher Newhall of the USGS in Reston was the second speaker, talking on "Eruption vs. erosion at Pinatubo Volcano: where will it end?"  Chris emphasized events before and since the main eruption of June, 1991.   Early volcanism in the area approximately one million years ago produced an andesitic cone and associated dacite domes.  Large pyroclastic eruptions began 30,000 yrs ago, yielding 10-15 km3 of dacitic flows and tuffs, and a crater comparable in size to that of Krakatoa in 1883; this volcanism produced the "modern Pinatubo."   For about the last 500 yrs, Pinatubo has been quiet, until July and August of 1990, when a magnitude 7 earthquake and steaming occurred.  Small explosive eruptions took place from April through June of 1991, with a ten-fold increase in SO2 emissions.  Magma mixing of previously erupted dacite and newly intruded basalt formed a porphyritic andesite, not a dacite, dome.   The "big one," as Chris called it, erupted an estimated 7-11 km3 of material on June 15, making it one of the three or four largest volcanic eruptions of this century.   In addition to the damage from ash, major lahars have created widespread erosion and destroyed many bridges and buildings; in total more than 100,000 people are homeless.  Because there is still much easily eroded pyroclastic material on and surrounding the volcano (in part as a function of low rainfall in 1992), mudflows still pose a great danger to the region in the near future.   This talk ran 21 minutes.  Questions by Moto Sato, Peter Schultz, Paul Silber, Bill Burton, Gene Robertson, and Bruce Lipin.

     The last talk of the evening was presented by Sean Solomon of DTM here in Washington, who spoke on "Venus: global tectonics and re-surfacing history."  Venus has a massive CO2 atmosphere, a continuous cloud cover,  500ēC surface temperatures, a lack of water, a lack of sedimentation, no plate tectonics. and no major erosion. Sean's talk used the side-looking radar images obtained by Magellan that now cover 98% of the surface of the planet, with approximately 300 meters resolution.  Venus has three times the land area of Earth, and according to Sean is a "hard rockers dream"  (although the cafe is not yet operating). Based on crater morphology, the average age of the surface is 500 million years.  A variety of tectonic features was illustrated, including 1500-km-long rifts decorated by volcanic centers, abundant normal faulting, and distinctive fold-and- thrust belts.   Sean also described the huge Maxwell area that has an elevation of 8-11 km and a steep western slope of about 30°, which seems difficult for the crust to support at 500ēC, unless the uplift is very recent.   The craters on Venus are especially intriguing, because they are not covered or filled in, suggesting that they may be removed by deformation, rather than erosion.   Sean proposed that all of the craters formed during the past 500 million years, after the surface was "cleaned" by an unknown internal mechanism.   This talk was also 21 minutes long.   Questions by George Helz, Bill Burton, Bob Ilchik, David Harding, Fred Walsh, Gene Robertson, Jodie Borgois, and Celia Murtsbacher.

     President Bethke adjourned the meeting, amidst a nearly full house of 98 attendees, at 9:51 p.m.

     Respectfully submitted,

     John F. Slack

     Meeting Secretary

 

MINUTES OF THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

1234th Meeting, January 27,  1993

     In the absence of President Bethke, Vice President Helz called the meeting to order at 8:02 p.m.   Five visitors were introduced: Janet Herman, John Berry, Dave Yerrington, Ed Landa, and Ann Kuebler.   One new member was announced, Adrian Abraham of George Washington University.   Tom Dutro publicized the centennial banquet on February 24th, and the meeting on the history of GSW on March 10th.   Vice President Helz also announced cancellation of the joint meeting with the Potomac Geophysical Society on March 18th, and reinstatement of the originally scheduled meeting of March 24th.   There were no informal communications.

     Robert Swap of the University of Virginia started the program with a talk on "Saharan dust in the Amazon Basin."   This project began with NASA boundary-layer experiments during 1985 and 1987, examining in part the composition of aerosols over the Amazon during the rainy season.  Anomalously high values of silica and chloride,  in particular, were interpreted as an indication of an easterly oceanic source, with the chloride derived presumably from seawater in the Atlantic Ocean.   The source of the silica, and also anomalous iron and alumina in the aerosols, was traced back by isobaric projections to near Lake Chad in the western Sahara.   NOAA satellite data that sense reflected radiation in the atmosphere were used together with information on atmospheric moisture to estimate the thickness and density of the aerosol layer.   Calculations using a divergence chart over the top four kilometers of the atmosphere above the Amazon showed an average of 50 micrograms per cubic meter of dust, and in places more than 400 micrograms per cubic meter.   Integration of the mean number of storms per year and their percentage coincidence with dust clouds suggests that approximately 13 million tons of dust enters the Amazon basin each year.   Because the dust also contains phosphorous, it may be significantly affecting the biosphere, and the long-term influence of the dust on the ecosystems of the Amazon should be considered.   Total time = 18 minutes.   Questions by Greg Stone, David Swartz, J.K. Bohlke, John Berry,  Bruce Lipin,  E-an Zen,  and Bob Ilchik.

     The second talk of the evening was presented by William Boyle of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, entitled "Structural analysis of Mount Rushmore National Memorial."  This study was undertaken for the Mount Rushmore Memorial Society, based on concerns regarding stability of the monument.   Doane Robinson conceived the monument in 1923, but the major impetus came from Gutzon Borglum, whose work was completed in 1941.   The monument is composed of the Early Proterozoic Harney Peak Granite, which sits atop a pelitic schist unit and contains many fractures and pegmatites, the weathering of the latter producing a false sense of major jointing.   Bill described various early efforts at repair work on Mount Rushmore, which may have been the first Presidential Face Lifts.  The main problem with the monument involves the possibility of falling blocks because of failure along fractures and joints.   A map was made to show these features, and stereonets and equal-area nets were used to analyze fractures and joints in three dimensions.   Evaluation of the stability of the blocks suggests that Mount Rushmore is safe and secure, which is supported by the fact that no pieces have fallen off over the past 50 years since completion of the monument.   Total time = 18.5 minutes. Questions by Laura Dwyer, Adrian Abraham, Bill Houser, and Margaret Chauncey.

     The last talk of the evening, by William Back, Edward Landa, and James McNeal of the USGS in Reston and by Lisa Meeks of the Arkansas Mining Institute, was entitled "Historical notes on bottled water, Hot Springs, Arkansas, and lesser spas."   Bill gave us a worldwide tour of the history and benefits of hot springs, using examples from the United States, Turkey, Germany, England, and France.   Hot Springs, Arkansas, was a favorite for Presidents like Hoover and FDR, and this talk was in fact a testimonial to how hot water can follow a President from Arkansas to Washington.   President Andrew Jackson set aside Hot Springs, Arkansas, as a national resource in 1833, and a military hospital was established there in 1888; it is now under the jurisdiction of the National Park Service.   The hot springs at Bath, England, were noteworthy for their medicinal benefits,  including alleged cures for "The Scratch" and the "Weakness of Any Member"  (I'll leave these diseases to your imagination).   The French hot springs are academically famous because they were used in the first geochemical studies of water, by physicians interested in how the chemistry of the hot springs affected their patients. Early studies of hot springs were made by such 18th Century geochemical luminaries as Joseph Priestly, Antoine Lavoisier, and William Henry.   Bill concluded his talk by urging the audience to join the "BMW Society" for those interested in "Bottled Mineral Waters."  This talk was a tardy 21.5 minutes.   Questions by Moto Sato, Bill Howser, and Bob Neuman.

     Following a round of applause for departing Program Chair J.K. Bohlke, Vice President Helz adjourned the meeting, with 77 attendees, at 9:37 p.m.

     Respectfully submitted,

     John F. Slack

     Meeting Secretary

 

MINUTES OF THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

1235th Meeting, February 10, 1993

     President Bethke called the meeting to order at 8:09 p.m.  Seven new members were announced including Gregory Walsh of the USGS, Athene Cua who is job hunting, Stephen Lynton of the University of Maryland, William Boyle of the NRC, Anne Kuebler of the USGS, Alan Linde of DTM, and Janet Herman of the University of Virginia.   No visitors were announced.  John Jens of the Public Service Committee reminded us of the upcoming spring science fairs, and solicited volunteers to act as judges.   Gene Robertson again announced the GSW Banquet on February 24th.   There were no informal communications.

     Jim Luhr of the Smithsonian started the program with a talk on "The Mexican Volcano Paricutin on its 50th Birthday: Finding the Parental Basalt."  Paricutin first erupted in a corn field in 1943, eventually growing over ten years to a height of 2200 meters.  Jim showed several old photos of the early life of the volcano, and recounted stories of the local residents including a reported "exorcism" by the village priest of the first bombs from the volcano.   Early work on Paricutin was done by William Foshag and Howell Williams, among others; Ray Wilcox proved early on that Bowen's reaction series failed to adequately explain the petrology of the volcano, and suggested that crustal assimilation played an important role in local magma generation.  A volcanic bomb collected in the first 90 minutes of the 1943 eruption proved to be critical, as it has both olivine and plagioclase phenocrysts, and a very Mg-rich bulk composition.   Jim proposed that this bomb represents a sample of the primitive parental basalt at Paricutin, which he documented with data from whole- rock chemistry and Sr, Nd, and Pb isotopes.  More evolved magma compositions that were identified in later eruptions apparently were produced by crustal assimilation, consistent with the presence of granitic xenoliths in some of the samples.   Questions y Moto Sato, Gene Robertson, Bill Houser. Dan Milton, Dave Stewart, and E-an Zen.  This talk was a tidy 19.5 minutes.

     The second talk of the evening was presented by Fred Phillips of New Mexico Tech  entitled  "Classification and Climate. A New Look as the Glacial Chronology of the Sierra Nevada."  This is the 62nd anniversary of the publication of a classic paper by Elliott Blackwelder on Pleistocene glaciations in the Sierra.   Fred reexamined Blackwelder's study area west of Bishop, California, on the east side of the Sierra, and mapped 14 terminal moraines. He used new methods for establishing the glacial chronology, including 36C1 and 14C dating of rock varnish on glacial boulders, and cation ratios and microstratigraphy of the varnish.  Samples show a systematic stratigraphic trend, with data from the oldest mapped moraines yielding ages of 180,000 years, and the youngest about 14,000 years.   Microprobe studies also show manganese-rich intervals in the rock varnish that correlate with colder temperatures.   The results of Fred's work suggest seven major glacial events over the past 190,000 years, with roughly equivalent magnitudes of ice advance in each event.  Blackwelder in contrast only documented two glacial events, arguing for the importance of "obliterative overlap" involving the covering of older moraines by younger moraines.   Blackwelder's thesis of obliterative overlap is thus supported, but his proposed glacial stages for the Sierra have little chronological significance. There were no questions from the audience.  This talk was 19.0 minutes long.

     The last talk, by Roy Dokka of LSU and NSF, was on "Tectonic Context of the 1992 Landers Earthquake."  Recent work over the past few years has reconstructed the style of faulting in the Mojave Desert region, resulting in a new way of looking at modern tectonics in southeastern California.   This area is important for understanding modern seismicity because 15 to 25 percent of current plate motion is accommodated on faults east of the San Andreas.  Roy's approach was to examine in detail map relations of fault blocks in the Mojave, and to reconstruct the geometry of the blocks through slip analysis.   South of the Garlock Fault and east of the San Andreas Fault, a major dextral shear zone 65 to 80 kilometers wide has developed over the last 10 million years.  The Garlock Fault on the west side of the study area formed early, and can be used as a strain marker; the 20-kilometer-long Granite Mountains Fault on the east, of Quaternary age, is currently inactive.   Shear in the Mojave is accommodated by translation along strike-slip faults, and by rotation about vertical axes on the fault blocks.   Young basalt flows dated at 2.5 million years are associated with movement along the strike-slip faults.  The results of this study help constrain models for the generation of earthquakes in southeastern California and elsewhere.   Questions by Moto Sato, Bob Ilchik, E-an Zen, George Helz, George Sellers, Doug Rumble, A1 Linde, and Gene Robertson.  This talk also was 19.0 minutes long.

     President Bethke adjourned the meeting, with 94 attendees, at 9:50 p.m.

     Respectfully submitted,

     John F.  Slack

     Meeting Secretary

 

MINUTES OF THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

1236th Meeting, March 10, 1993

     President Bethke called the meeting to order at 8:01 p.m. Two new members were announced, Mike Carr of the USGS and Gantam Sen of NSF. The following visitors were introduced: John Price, Ellie Brouwer, Tom Bown, John Barron, Derrick Kaiser, and Whitman Cross II. The death of Felix Chayes of the Geophysical Lab was also announced. President Bethke reminded us of John Jens' need of judges for upcoming science fairs in the D.C. area, and read letters by John Reed, Art Baker, and Ken Lohman that congratulated the Society on the occasion of its 100th birthday. There were no informal communications.

     Ellis Yochelson of the Smithsonian started the program with a talk on "Founding of the Geological Society of Washington---Who?, What?, When?, Where?, WHY?" Ellis gave us a Linnaean look at the early founders of GSW, including C.D. Walcott, a loyal family man who never went to college, and other luminaries such as J. Stanley Brown, J.S. Diller, and G.K. Gilbert. The first organizational meeting was held on February 25, 1893, which followed the founding of other early Washington scientific societies including the Philosophical Society of Washington (1871), the Anthropological Society of Washington (1879), the National Geographic Society (1888), and the Biological Society of Washington (1889). Ellis speculated that GSW was founded because Walcott, in response to major Congressional budget cuts to the USGS in 1892, thought that a local geological society would be good for USGS morale. Questions by Marty Toulmin, Patrick Taylor, Dan Milton, and Whitman Cross II. This talk was 20.5 minutes.

     The second talk of the evening, presented by Gene Robertson of the USGS, was entitled "The Founders and the Significant Papers of 100 Years of GSW." Gene gave us a short overview of the geological interests and work of the founders of the Society. Seven founders had careers that mainly involved field mapping: Florence Bascom, Joseph Diller, N.H. Darton, Arthur Hague, Arthur Keith, George Merrill, and W.J. McGee. F.W. Clarke, Waldemar Schaller, and N.L. Bowen worked principally on experimental mineralogy and geochemistry. Mapping of mining districts was the specialty of Alfred Brooks, Arthur Spencer, S.F. Emmons, Waldemar Lindgren, and W.H. Weed. George Hayes, Francois Matthes, and H.W. Turner worked on Pleistocene glaciation and geomorphology. Stream erosion and water quality were studied by F.H. Newell. C.D. Walcott, F.H. Knowlton, and T.W. Stanton were noted stratigraphers and paleontologists. Bailey Willis mainly worked on structure and tectonics, and G.K. Gilbert on isostatic adjustment and emplacement of igneous intrusions. Coal deposits were studied by M.R. Campbell, D.T. Day, G.H. Eldridge, and C.D. White. Gene briefly mentioned several key papers presented before the society, such as that by Whitman Cross and others on the CIPW classification of igneous rocks, and more recent ones by Anita Harris and Dave Stewart on conodants and crustal structure, respectively. Gene also emphasized the importance of radiogenic isotope studies to many papers given at GSW, noting that such studies have "almost put paleontology out of business." Amidst hisses and boos from a vocal minority in the audience, there were no questions. (14.0 minutes).

     Tom Dutro of the USGS presented the third talk on "Ambience, Humor, and Audiences Through 100 Years of GSW Meetings." Tom opened by noting that during the first quarter-century, GSW meetings were formal black tie affairs, with all officers of the society wearing black tie until the end of the 1920s. Tom mystified the audience by implying a connection between the solemnity of the meetings and the scarcity of women members; the latter, according to Tom, was also somehow related to the formal attire worn by the men in the society. Florence Bascom was an early member, and in 1901 gave the first talk by a woman, on the geology of the Philadelphia Gneiss. Tom told us that since the founding of the society, the proportion of women in GSW has increased steadily, from 2 percent in 1893, to 5 percent in 1943, to 13 percent in 1975, and finally to 23 percent in 1990; he didn't tell us, however, if there was a corresponding increase in levity. In terms of attendance, the early years until about 1905 saw an average of 30-40 people in the audience, which rose dramatically to 130-150 during the period 1950 to 1970. Since then, there has been a considerable decline in meeting attendance (to an average of about 80 to 90), which many people feel is related to the USGS move to Reston in 1972. Tom finished with a discussion on the Sleeping Bear Award, which was established in 1953 following presentation of the paper "Why Bears Sleep Through the Winter." Tom recounted highlights of previous awardees' exploits, which have been largely overshadowed by Dave Stewart's wearing of a bear skin when he presented the award in 1968; Stewart only has three Sleeping Bear Awards, however, and is still behind front-runner Ellis Yochelson who has four. Questions by Moto Sato, Ellis Yochelson, Meyer Rubin (who complained that he was funny, too), Patrick Taylor, Peter Lyttle, and Phil Bethke. This talk was 15.5 minutes long.

     The last formal talk of the evening was presented by Pete Toulmin, retired from the USGS, on "GSW and the Cosmos Club." The Cosmos Club was formed almost exclusively from members of the Philosophical Society of Washington, who, according to Pete, felt the need for a more relaxed, social atmosphere than that offered by the Philosophical Society. Most early members of GSW were also members of the Cosmos Club, including 79 of the initial 109 members, and all of the early officers of GSW. The Cosmos Club was founded at the home of John Wesley Powell, mainly by scientists, and 72 of 90 past presidents of GSW have belonged to the Cosmos Club. Questions by Bill Back, Meyer Rubin, Patrick Taylor, Doug Kinney, and Phil Bethke. This talk was 16 minutes.

     Jim Luhr of the Smithsonian was scheduled to present "Eruption of Paricutin: Marking the 50th Anniversary of GSW," but unfortunately was out of town. Jeff Grossman of the USGS substituted, narrating a movie that included film clips of the early 1943 eruptions of this famous Mexican volcano. This movie was shown to GSW in 1943 by William Foshag of the Smithsonian, who had visited Paracutin just one month after its initial eruption. In addition to black-and-white newsreel footage, the movie included color film shot only eight days after the first eruption. Color film taken at night by Fred Poe was especially spectacular, showing huge incandescent lava fountains on the summit. When it was presented at GSW in 1943, this movie attracted 224 people, one of the highest attendances ever recorded by the society. With luck, someone in the audience may again show this movie on the 150th birthday of GSW, in February, 2043.

     Following a standing ovation for Gene Robertson for chairing the centennial committee, President Bethke adjourned the meeting, with 98 attendees, at 9:57 pm.

     Respectfully submitted,

     John F. Slack

     Meeting Secretary

 

GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

MINUTES OF 1237TH MEETING

MARCH  24,  1993

     Vice-President Roz Helz called the meeting to order at 8:04 p.m. New members Jon Price and Andrew Kulp were announced.   Aro Hanski, Ann Landfield, Aro Senkhe, Mary Baxter, Dick Sheldon, and Jeannie Hewwitt were introduced as guests.  John Jens, Public Service Committee Chairman, reported on the upcoming Science Fairs, and Gene Robertson described the recently published GSW Centennial Volume and pictures taken at the banquet.

     William Melson of the Smithsonian presented the first talk on the probability of volcanic eruptions at Yucca Mountain.   Yucca Mountain has been chosen as a nuclear waste repository because of the low human population density and high depths to groundwater. The area is the site of recent volcanism, including Lathrop Wells that has been active in the past 10,000 to 13,000 years.   To evaluate the probability of an eruption or intrusion into the waste repository a probability model has been developed with the following parameters:   1) Eruption probabilities in the region, 2) Probability of an eruption causing the release of radioactive materials.   Assessing these probabilities is difficult due to the time spacing of the eruptions and the spatial distribution of eruptive centers.   Questions by Ron Brice, Dan Milton, an unknown person, Leon Panetta, and Dennis Krohn.

     The second talk was by James Hays of NSF, who discussed the role that Francis Birch played in developing interest in experiments in mineral phases at high pressures.   The work that Birch conducted in the 1950s has stimulated 40 years of research to date.   Birch recognized that seismic data showed that olivine, pyroxene, and garnets were probable mantle materials.   The research that Birch conducted and inspired set the stage for modern research in diamond anvil apparati.  Hays kept his talk to 20 minutes and showed us pictures of Gene Robertson in his grad student days.  Remembrances of Francis Birch were offered by Gene Robertson, Doug Rumble, Dave Stewart, and Joe Boyd, in lieu of questions.

     The final talk of the evening was by James Monsees on the design and construction of the superconducting supercollider.   The tunnels are 54 miles in length and are being dug south of Dallas for a cost of 8 billion dollars.   Tunnels are burrowed through Austin chalk, shale, and marl.  The chalk is a competent layer that is self-supporting; the other layers are overstressed at depth and require tunnel linings and structural support.   Once vertical access tunnels are drilled or reamed out, the tunnels are drilled with mechanical moles that have heads resembling dentist drills. Due to recession in the construction industry and good luck with tunneling equipment, the construction phase is currently 80 million under budget.   Questions by Jane Hammarstrom, Mary Baxter, E-an Zen, Gene Robertson, George Helz, Dennis Krohn, Jim Hays, Roberta Dillenburg, and one unidentified individual.

     The meeting adjourned at 9:40 and was attended by 68 people.

     Respectfully submitted

     Karen Prestegaard (for John Slack)

 

MINUTES OF THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

1238th Meeting, April 14,  1993

     President Bethke called the meeting to order at 8:02 p.m.   One new member, Richard P.  Shelton, was announced.   Only one guest was introduced, David Simpson of Lamont-Doherty Geological Observatory.   The deaths of A1 Froelich and Norm Sohl were announced.   John Jens, Chairman of the Public Service Committee, again asked for volunteers to be judges at local science fairs.  Liz Koosmin, editor of the GSW newsletter Outcrops, requested contributions, help, and suggestions for the next issue.   Gene Robertson reminded us that he still has a book of pictures from the GSW banquet that we can use for choosing duplicates.   Tom Dutro also announced that Mike Fleischer has just submitted to Mineralogical Abstracts his 92,000th abstract.

     Dick Fiske of the Smithsonian started the program with a talk on "One-Rift, Two-Rift Paradox at Kilauea Volcano, Hawaii."  Dick described the well-known east and southwest rift zones on the south flank of Kilauea, and showed various surface manifestations of these rifts.  Another way to look at the rifting process, however,  is with seismicity, which is systematically south of the two surface traces of the rifts.   This is in contrast to the gravity data that coincide with the rifts.   One interpretation is that there has been migration of the rifts to the south, towards the ocean.   Recent studies by Dick (together with Tim Rose and Don Swanson) of tephra and thick ponded flows within the east-west Koae rift, which lies between the east and southwest rifts, reveal the nature of rift-related faulting.   Based on these data and new GLORIA studies off the south coast of the island that show huge slumps or breakaways, Dick suggested that the two rift zones on the Big Island are actually part of a headland scarp in which rifting is associated with shield destruction, rather than shield growth.   Questions by Bob Ilchik, Patrick Taylor, Peter Stifel,  Bob Neuman, A1 Linde, Bevin French, Doug Rankin,  and Ann Dorr.   (21 minutes).

     The second talk was presented by Connie Sancetta of NSF and Lamont-Doherty Geological Observatory, on "High Primary Production in the Glacial North Atlantic and Pacific Oceans: The Iceberg Hypothesis."  Connie compared the productivity of the North Atlantic and North Pacific Oceans, showing that Spring blooms are important in the Atlantic, while none occur in the Pacific; that the Atlantic is dominated by diatoms, while the Pacific is dominated by Picoplankton; and that the Atlantic biomass is ten times that of the Pacific.  Marginal seas, however, are highly productive in both oceans at northerly latitudes,  including Baffin Bay in the North Atlantic and the Sea of Okhotsk in the North Pacific.   The sediment record and microfossils give us data on past conditions going back 18,000-20,000 years, to the time of the last glacial event.   Two sediment cores in the North Pacific show major changes at 12,000 years ago in the diatom assemblages, and an order of magnitude more productivity than in the same area today.   One possible explanation for these relations suggested by Connie is that the higher productivity of the North Pacific 12,000 years ago may have been responsible for the loss of CO2 in the atmosphere at the time, the latter recently revealed by low CO2 contents in ice cores.   Connie proposed that icebergs in the northern oceans generated changes in biologic productivity through the physical presence of the icebergs causing upwelling of nutrients from below the pycnocline, and through the presence of clays and mineral particles within the icebergs that provided increased nutrients for greater productivity.   Questions by Tom Dutro, George Helz, E-an Zen, Gene Robertson, Meyer Rubin, Doug Rankin, and Ken Towe.   (15 minutes).

     The last talk of the evening was presented by Dave Russ of the USGS in Reston on "Maryland Earthquakes 1993: What's All the Fuss About?"  Dave described the recent earthquakes in the Columbia, Maryland, area and their implications.  The first significant quake was a magnitude 2.7 event on March 10, which apparently was preceded by several smaller quakes two days before.   Since the initial shock,  11 other measurable quakes have been recorded in the area, with magnitudes in the range 1.8 to 2.7.   Seismograms show that for the first quake, S- and P waves arrived nearly simultaneously, thus indicating a very shallow depth; calculated hypocenters are about 0.5 kilometers.   Such low-magnitude, shallow earthquakes are felt more readily and widely than 5- to 10-kilometer deep quakes in California that generally are felt only if they have magnitudes of 3 or greater.  Another interesting aspect of the Maryland earthquakes is that their focal plane mechanisms suggest a northwest-trending reverse fault solution.   No northwest-trending faults, either inactive or active, are known in the area, but 11 earthquakes near Richmond, Virginia,  in 1986-1987 also had a northwest-trending fault solution.   Several hypotheses have been proposed to explain these and similar shallow earthquakes in the eastern U.S., including the presence of Mesozoic dikes and related density contrasts with surrounding country rocks, chemical weathering, and release of long-term strain due to hydrofracturing.  Questions by Gene Robertson, Meyer Rubin,  Bevin French, Antonia Segovia, Jim Reger, Al Linde, Moto Sato, Robert Schneider, and Doug Rankin.   (19 minutes).

     President Bethke adjourned the meeting at 9:44 p.m., with 85 attendees present.

     Respectfully submitted,

     John F. Slack

     Meeting Secretary

 

GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

MINUTES OF 1239th MEETING

APRIL  28,  1993

     President Phil Bethke convened the 1239th meeting of the Society at 8:05 p.m.   Minutes of the 1238th meeting were read and approved.   One guest was introduced, Adele Connor from the Smithsonian.   Don Hadley and Dick Sheldon, who had been on foreign assignments for a number of years, were welcomed back to membership.   E-an Zen requested volunteers for C & O canal treks, and Gene Robertson announced that he is taking orders for photos from the Centennial Banquet.

     Tom Messenger presented an informal communication on photographs of mountains named after founding members of GSW, based on journal excerpts from the 1869 Powell Survey.

     Bob Ilchik, Geophysical Laboratory, spoke on "Hydrothermal circulation, 40 million years of extension, and 200 million ounces of gold: A perspective on the development of the Great Basin."  Bob presented a model for the generation of Carlin type disseminated gold deposits in which sediments provide the metals, meteoric water provides the transport mechanism,  and extensional tectonics provide a driving force for circulation that uses magmas as a heat engine, rather than as a source for metals.   The premise of this model is that during extension and thinning of crust, geothermal gradients are perturbed.   The talk ran a tad long - 24 minutes - and prompted questions by Van Oss, Milton, Lipin,  Zen, and Barton.

     The second speaker was L. Douglas James of the National Science Foundation and Utah State University, who presented a talk entitled "Venturing into stochastic parametric hydrogeologic modeling."   In reconstructing these minutes for posterity, I discovered that neither "stochastic" nor "parametric" are listed in my computer thesaurus, although the "near alphabet guesses" that the thesaurus provided,  in particular the words "stimulating" and "paradoxical" can be applied to this talk, depending on one's point of view.   Dr. James described his methods for finding the optimum scale for surface water modeling of rainfall runoff for ungaged water cachements by estimating model parameters from cachement characteristics and hydrologic principles.   The power of this technique is that if the scale can be optimized using data for climate and topography, field work can be minimized to collection of stream flow data.   Questions by Van Oss (3), Gene Robertson, Karen Prestergaard, and Bob Ilchik.   (20 minutes)

     The final talk of the evening was given by Andrei V. Sher of the Russian Academy of Sciences, who charmed us with his discussion of "Mammoth extinction and arctic environment: New Evidence."  The discovery of 4,000 to 7,000 year old dwarf mammoth teeth on Wrangel Island in the Siberian Arctic shows that mammoths did not become extinct by 9,500 years ago as previously thought.   Local topography and climate conditions supported a relict steppe habitat on Wrangel Island that permitted the survival of the mammoths in the face of a trend towards an unfavorable Holocene environment.   The talk was very long, but so interesting that nobody cared.  Questions by Helz, Milton, and Volt.  Attendance was 50.   The meeting was adjourned at 10:10 p.m.

     Respectfully submitted,

     Jane Hammarstrom (for John Slack)

 

GEOLOGICAL  SOCIETY  OF  WASHINGTON 

1240th Meeting, September 15, 1993

     President Phil Bethke convened the 1240th meeting of the Society at 8:04 p.m.  Minutes of the 1239th meeting were read and approved.  74 members and guests were present.  Guests introduced were Jin Ugang (China). John Holloway, Steve Kessler, Margaret and David Oliver (U.K.), Murray Hitzman, Maeve Boland (GS Ireland), Beth Price, Steve Clark, and Sarah Marcus.

     E-an Zen announced a field trip he and Karen Prestergaard will lead 3 November to Great Falls (Virginia side), to look at river channel and pothole development.

     Phil Bethke mentioned that volunteers would be welcomed by "Environmentors," a group striving to reach out to inner-city children and bring to them an awareness of science and the environment.

     The resignation of Liz Koosmin as newsletter editor was reported. along with a call for a volunteer to replace her.

     Margaret Chauncey reported that the State of Maryland has an announcement out for a geologist position in Baltimore, with a very short deadline for applications.

     Jonathan Price. National Research Council, opened the program with a talk having the sensuously alliterative title. "Rhyolites and the rationale for radon regulation."  It was noted that EPA radon risk assignments for a whole state may be made on the basis of a single radon measurement.  This did not appear to be a terribly good way to characterize a geologically diverse state like Nevada, and offered a great excuse to go to the field and look at neat rhyolites and determine their radon emanations.  Topaz rhyolites known to be relatively high in radioactivity were chosen for study, and measurements were made using 50 instruments borrowed from EPA.  The data had a lot of scatter. but showed general correlation of levels of radon in air and levels of radon in soil.  Numbers like 17 and even 32 pCi/L were found in natural settings. to be contrasted with EPA's notion that 4 pCi/L is the threshold for consideration as hazardous.  The speaker handled the topic with diplomacy and circumspection. but an alert listener might have concluded that the EPA approach to the problem is completely free of any taint of geoscience and perhaps could be reinvented, along with the rest of government.  The talk inspired a very interesting group of questions, almost a discussion, from Doe,  Ross, Tanner, Nancy Milton. Zen, Schieffers, Oliver, Ilchik, and Namula.  The hazard or risk assessment aspect was likened to the misguided and incredibly expensive asbestos scare; and it was pointed out that for most areas of the US. the natural incidence of radon commonly is higher than that found at nuclear plants or the Nevada Test Site.  Mention was made of a data set, 40 years of measurements in Sweden, that apparently is quite inconsistent with similar data for the US; exchange of questions did not seem to resolve this discrepancy.  17 minutes)

     The second talk was by Christopher Maples, Kansas Geological Survey, on "Implications of a latest Devonian Chinese echinoderm fauna."  In starkly rocky desert at the west edge of the Gobi. one apparently finds strewn fields of weathered-out virtually perfect specimens of crinoids, blastoids, and related fossils.  The collecting for this study tripled the world's supply of specimens of such critters from the Fammenian.  The new collection offered two important insights:  With this larger sample there is not a sharp break corresponding to the widespread faunal extinction commonly noted for the Frasnian-Fammenian boundary.  And, the Devonian echinoderm distribution suggests an expansion of the tropics farther north than previously thought, helping to explain why paleoecologic plate reconstructions have interpreted the continents to be farther south than seen in paleomagnetic reconstructions.  Not 1east of the breakthroughs was the serendipitous discovery that Liquid Plumr works to dissolve rock from around the fossils (DO NOT TRY THIS AT HOME).  Questions by Hitzman and Dutro. (17 minutes)

     The last talk was by Gautam Sen. Florida International University and NSF, on "Trapped mantle melts."  The focus was on the chemistry and petrology of glass contained in xenoliths found in Hawaiian lavas. and considered to provide samples of mantle.  Two types found are hydrous, amphibole-rich glass. and anhydrous glass without amphibole.  The glass occurs in elongate patches between grains or along annealed intragrain cracks.  Melt composition falls generally along a trend seen in such materials worldwide. separated from the composition of the host basalt by the well-known 'Daly Gap.'  Sen attributed the gap to differences caused by vapor saturation of the melts vs. vapor-free character of the host rocks.  Comparison of melt and wallrock indicated no interaction, no metasomatic effect on the minerals enclosing the melts.  Interpretation of P-T indicators suggested that the hydrous melts originated in the asthenosphere (60-75 km) and held their volatiles during their rise and emplacement, and that the anhydrous melts were more likely generated by decompression melting during rise and emplacement.  Questions by Doe, Holloway, Ross. Bethke, Robertson, Chauncey, and Ryan. (22 minutes)

     The meeting was adjourned at 9:42 p.m.

     Respectfully submitted.

     Terry Offield (for John Slack)

 

Geological Society of Washington

Minutes of the 1241st Meeting

September 29, 1993

     Due to a number of missing links in the chain of command, Secretary John Slack presided over the meeting, which he formally commenced at 8:02 p.m.   Five actual guests were introduced   Mei Shillong, Jill Schneiderman, Fred Kier,  ? Vasiley, and Raquel Jones.   Peter Stifel started a new and hopefully short-lived trend by introducing Mario Marchusio, who was not present, but should have been, according to Stifel.

     Raquel Jones of "The Environmentors Project" gave a brief introduction to her mentoring program which pairs disadvantaged D.C. high school students with scientists to conduct environmental research and community service projects.   Citing herself as "living proof" of the merits of such programs, Miss Jones asked members of GSW to consider participating in the program which involves a 4-month commitment from the scientist.   See Kathy Krohn for application forms and additional information.

     The first speaker of the evening was Debra Willard, U.S. Geological Survey, on "Pollen record from the North Atlantic Region at 3 Ma: Vegetational distribution during a period of global warmth".   Debra examined the fossil pollen and spore record for 5 North Atlantic Pliocene sites dated by paleomagnetic reversals.   By comparing the fossil record with modern vegetation patterns, she is able to  compute dissimilarity coefficients which allows her to contrast the fossil climate with modern climates in which particular plant communities are found.   For three Arctic sites the pollen record is dominated by mixed conifer hardwoods including oak, hemlock, maple, and European holly.  These types of vegetation are restricted to lower latitudes and higher temperatures than exist at these sites today,  indicating that the Pliocene was on the order of 3 to 4 degrees warmer. Pollen from sites farther south, near Yorktown, VA and a subtropical site off SW Florida indicates that the Pliocene climate was similar to the present climate.    In the Pliocene, conifer forests extended as far as 80ēN and there is very little evidence for the tundra that characterizes today's northern Atlantic regions anywhere in the Pliocene pollen record.   Questions by George Helz, Yvette Ogel, Cy Galvin, and Jingle Ruppert.

     Silvia Garzoli of Lamont Doherty and NSF presented the second talk on "The Oceanic Circulation in the Southwestern Atlantic and its implication for Climates and Local Economics,, As part of the continuing effort to obtain data on ocean boundary conditions to construct more accurate climate prediction models, Silvia uses inverted echosounders to map the direction of flow, velocity, and location of water masses of the Brazil and Malvinas currents, the western boundary currents in the South Atlantic that are analogous to the Gulf Stream in the northern hemisphere.  Because the Brazil current is weak, it is influenced by winds. Normal winds patterns push the Brazil current south.   In 1988, an anomalous year, a negative, or northerly circulation pattern disrupted the normal current directions and carried the water, along with its resident fish, away from Argentine fishermen who consequently had a very bad year.    Putting data for real winds into circulation models is a way to forecast anomalous currents.  Questions by Kevin Crowley, E-an Zen, Peter Stifel, Alan Linde, Moto Sato, and Robert Schneider.

     The program ended back on dry land with Don Steeples of the University of Kansas who spoke on "Environmental Applications of Shallow Seismic Reflection".   Reflection seismology is a relatively low cost technique that can be used for depth to bedrock studies, finding faults, identifying sand lenses in clay or clay in sands, and locating cavities or karsts.   Don described his equipment and explained how "safe seismology" is done using 50 caliber machine guns and 30.06 rifles as the source for an air blast with condoms to keep out water and the ever dispensable graduate students to help muffle the noise.   He described case studies in which he used seismic reflection to help supplement test well data on structure to track leaks around chemical stor- age ponds and detect abandoned coal mines.   The scale of the data is such that one meter by 10 meter scale sand lenses can be detected.    Questions by Gene Robertson, Moto Sato, Bruce Lipin, and Jill Schneiderman.

     The meeting was adjourned at 9:45 p.m.. Attendance was 63.

     Respectfully submitted,

     Jane Hammarstrom (for John Slack)

 

MINUTES OF THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

1242nd Meeting, October 13,  1993

     President Bethke opened the meeting at 8:05 p.m.   Seven new members were announced, including Vasile Rusu, Nicholas Woodward, Frederick Keer, Douglas Brown, Jody Bourgeois, Daniel Chadwick, and Michael Saint Clair.   Five quests were introduced: Christine Larsen, James McCullough, Curt Lindsay, Donald Haney, and Gramene Richardson.   E-an Zen announced the upcoming GSW field trip on November 13 to Great Falls National Park.   Present Bethke also announced the publication of reviews in Science and in the Historical Geology Section of GSA of the centennial GSW volume on the history of our society.   There were no informal communications.

     Alan Linde of DTM started the program with a talk entitled "The 1991 Eruption of Hekla as Seen Through the Non-Blinking Eyes of Borehole Strainmeters."  Alan described the application of a new type of strainmeter that was used to decipher volcanotectonic events in Iceland in 1991.   Data were acquired from a strainmeter inserted into wet grout in a borehole approximately 100 to 200 meters deep.  Expansion of the grout during cooling locks the instrument into place and enhances sensitivity.   This strainmeter produces high- quality data, with a very large frequency range from 0 to 30 Hz. Alan used data for the month of January, 1991, for interpreting the nature of magma ascent during the eruption of Hekla that occurred on January 17th.  No warnings of the eruption were noted, and no seismicity was recorded beforehand.  At 5:00 p.m., nothing was observed at the surface, but 10 minutes later, a plume 11.5 kilometers high was seen over the volcano.   Using the data from the strainmeter and the inferred depth to the magma chamber of 4 kilometers, Alan calculated that the magma ascended at a rate of 8-10 kilometers per hour.  A model involving deflation of a deep magma source fits the data very well.   The model has good predictive capacity, and may be useful for monitoring volcanic hazards at other active volcanoes around the world.   Questions by Dave Stewart, Clinton Sandford, Moto Sato, Brooks Hanson, Bruce Lipin, and Leonard Johnson.   (22.0 minutes).

     The second speaker of the evening was Joanne Bourgeois of the University of Washington and NSF, who presented a talk on "Tsunami Deposits as Paleoseismicity Indicators."  Joanne reviewed the nature of tsunamis, which are "impulse-generated waves" that commonly are associated with subduction-related earthquakes, submarine landslides, and volcanic explosions.   Damaging tsunamis are mainly caused by earthquakes with magnitudes of 7.5 or greater.  The Cascadia subduction zone, developed on young crust, is likely to have produced large tsunamis in the past, although no modern earthquakes of significant magnitude have been linked to this subduction zone.   For comparative purposes, Joanne and colleagues studied tsunami deposits associated with the magnitude 9.5 earthquake in Chile in 1960, which is the largest historic earthquake ever measured.   Along the Chilean coast, a town was washed away, a forest was drowned and a thin sand layer a few centimeters thick was deposited within coastal estuaries.   The presence of similar sand layers in the area of Willapa Bay, Washington, together with the burial of cedar trees along the coast there, suggest the occurrence of a major Cascadia-related earthquake approximately 300 years ago.  Based on this occurrence, Joanne concluded that the Pacific Northwest--including Seattle and the Puget Sound area--has a potential for receiving tsunami deposits from a local earthquake.   Questions by Kevin Crowley, Cy Galvin, Dave Stewart, Peter Stifel, Murray Hitzman, E-an Zen, and Brooks Hanson.   (21.0 minutes).

     The last talk of the evening was by John LaBrecque of NASA and the Jet Propulsion Lab, who spoke on "Using Satellites to Study the Dynamic Earth."  The main focus of his work involves trying to understand the forces on the lithosphere, using GPS and related satellite-based systems such as lasers, radar, altimeters, gravimeters, and magnetometers.   In a global sense, these instruments can be used to study plate tectonics, post-glacial rebound, earthquake cycles, solid earth tides, oceanic tidal loading, and atmospheric loading.   John reviewed the applications of several satellite-based systems.   Global Positioning, or GPS systems, for example,  interact with more than 24 satellites and 42 current or planned receivers, which can provide locations that are accurate to 2 millimeters or less--if you have a military i.d.  Ocean-floor geodedic systems, which now can generate locations within 5 centimeters, already are in use off Vancouver Island, where they allow discrimination of continuous versus discontinuous motion on the Juan de Fuca plate.  GPS systems are also being used to detect crustal deformation, such as in the Landers area of southern California, and volcanic inflation, such as at Long Valley caldera.  John also briefly discussed other systems including synthetic aperture radar, which will soon be available after the launch of a new satellite, satellite ranger lasing, and very-long baseline interferometery.   Questions by Kathy Krohn, Alan Linde, and Dave Stewart.   (20.5 minutes).

     President Bethke adjourned the meeting at 9:50 p.m., with 79 attendees present.

     Respectfully submitted,

     John F. Slack

     Meeting Secretary

 

MINUTES OF THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

1243rd Meeting, November 3, 1993

     President Bethke opened the meeting at 8:04 p.m.   Four new members were announced, including Curt Lindsay, Murray Hitzman, Maeve Boland, and Louis Pribyl.   Ten guests were introduced: Winston Towe, Alexander Redkin, Maria Woitsekhovskaya, Margaruite Collins, Ray Russo, Jeff Park, John Vanderkow, Rick Carten, Richard Wonderman, and Derek Hutton.   President Bethke reminded the membership of the upcoming GSW field trip to Great Falls National Park on November 13, to be led by E-an Zen and Karen Prestergaard.   Phil then introduced Kathy Krohn, chairperson of the membership committee, who reported on proposed changes an the bylaws regarding new members.  Several changes were proposed, the chief one being election to GSW membership after receiving nominations from three current members and paying of dues- but without requiring a vote of approval by Council.  After much discussion--  some of it quite heated--a motion was passed to table the discussion until a future meeting.

     Cy Galvin, a local Washington-area consultant, presented an informal communication on his discovery of quartz-rich float in southeastern Fairfax County.   Cy interpreted this float as quartzite, and not vein quartz, which contradicts recently published USGS mapping that shows this area as being underlain by Occaquon granite.   Cy chose five "democratically selected" quartz-rich boulders, but no republican ones, for evaluation.  Concentric circles and spirals were interpreted as possible algal mats, and enigmatic weathering pits were proposed to be hornblende casts   Cy suggested that dolomitic marl is the protolith of amphibolite in contact with quartzite.  Questions by Peter Lyttle and Doug Rankin, accompanied by furrowed brows and head scratching in the audience.

     Murray Hitzman of the U.S. Congress opened the formal program with a presentation on "Discovery of the Carbonate-Hosted Lisheen Zn-Pb deposit, Republic of Ireland."  Murray described the results of a ten-year exploration program in southeastern Ireland in a region of poorly exposed Carboniferous carbonate rocks.   Exploration began in 1984, and following detailed stratigraphic, geochemical, and geophysical work, was followed by initial drilling in March, 1990.  The sixth drill hole intersected 14.2 meters of 13.8% zinc, 3.5% lead, and 1.6 ounces per ton silver, which has since become Ireland's most promising new metal discovery.  Murray outlined several strategic concepts that were used in his exploration program, including a model involving subseafloor replacement--and not exhalative precipitation; formation in the stratigraphically lowest clean carbonate unit, the presence of an alteration halo larger than the deposit; metal zoning within the deposit; and various structural controls.   Soil geochemical studies were considered critical, in particular the recognition of areas having as little as 125 ppm zinc, which previously was not identified as anomalous for the local carbonate terrane.   The importance of iron-rich dolomite alteration in the deposit area was also stressed, which contrasts with the iron-poor dolomite produced during regional dolomitization.   Preliminary carbon and oxygen isotope data for the ferroan dolomite show mixing lines between an inferred hydrothermal fluid and local carbonate rocks.   Based on several lines of evidence, Murray proposed that the fluid was derived, at least in part, from the Old Red Sandstone at depth.   Questions by Dave Stewart, Rick Wonderman, Julian Hemley, Moto Sato, Marcus Milling, Bruce Lipin, and Phil Bethke.   (20.0 minutes).

     The second speaker of the evening, Thomas Torgersen of the University of Connecticut and DOE, presented a talk on  Dating Fluids in Basin Scale Hydrogeologic Flow Systems."  Tom began by emphasizing our need to understand the roles of geologic time and fluid transport in crustal processes.  He used Darcy's Law as the basis for calculating the hydraulic age or residence time of basinal fluids.   After reviewing various isotopic tracers for groundwaters, Tom described the advantage of using  He because of its large flux through the continental crust.   Tom's method involves the vertical transport of helium in the crust as a means for dating fluids in basin-scale systems.  As a test of his method, Tom and a French colleague collected a large number of samples from the Paris basin.  Their results show increased helium flux with depth in different aquifers of the basin.   3He/4He ratios, normalized to air values, also increase with depth due to fluid input from adjacent crystalline massifs.   The 3He/4He profiles were used to calibrate vertical fluid flux.  Tom's calculations suggest that the water in the Dogger aquifer in the Paris basin is approximately 4 million years old, which is more geologically realistic than the previous estimates of several hundred thousand years.   This method can be used to define fluid transport in basins, including hydrothermal systems and petroleum-generating systems.   Questions by Alan Tanner, Moto Sato, Dave Stewart, and George Helz.   (18.5 minutes).

     Connie Bertka of the Geophysical Lab gave the last presentation, entitled "Partial Melting of an Iron-Rich Mantle: Implications for Melting Reactions in Planetary Interiors."  Connie described the results of experimental studies of iron-rich minerals at high pressure, and their use as guides to mantle compositions of Earth and Mars.  The mantle of Mars is believed to be more dense than that of Earth, in the range 3.47 to 3.66 grams per cubic centimeter, compared with 3.34 grams per cubic centimeter for Earth.  The calculation of mantle densities requires knowledge of the moment of inertia and bulk density, plus assumptions about the composition of the core.   If the high mantle density Calculated for Mars is correct, it implies an iron-rich composition; this is supported by the iron-rich nature of meteorites that are believed to have come from Mars.   Connie's experiments, carried out with anhydrous minerals in the range 10 to 30 kb, were designed to model this iron-rich mantle composition for the determination of solidus and liquidus temperatures and phase relations.  The experiments show that melting reactions that produce orthopyroxene will occur at a lower pressure on Mars than on Earth, that Ks, in the spinel instead of in the garnet stability field, unless the Martian mantle has peridotite element ratios, an which case orthopyroxene is not a stable solidus phase there at any pressure.  Questions by Moto Sato, Robin Brett, Alan Tanner, Gene Robertson, and Joe Boyd.   (22.0 minutes).

     President Bethke adjourned the meeting at 10:05 p.m. with 88 attendees present.

     Respectfully submitted,

     John F. Slack

     Meeting Secretary

 

MINUTES OF THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

1244th Meeting, November 17,  1993

     President Bethke opened the meeting at 8:03 p.m.  One new member was announced, Tom Armstrong, a new postdoc at the USGS in Reston.   Three guests were introduced, including Jeffrey Williams, Virginia Smith, and Edward Venske.   President Bethke read the slate of proposed new GSW officers and members of the Council, which will be voted on during the annual meeting on December 8.

     Scott Ishman of the USGS in Reston opened the program with a talk entitled "The Effect of Northern Hemisphere Warmth on Antarctic Ice Volume: A Look at the Pliocene."  Scott described the results of recent work under the auspices of the PRISM project, which is an acronym for "Pliocene Research, Interpretation, and Synoptic Mapping."  The Pliocene, and in particular the time from 3.5 to 2.0 million years ago, is of interest because it is the last period of significant warmth in Earth's history.   For global warming studies, the Pliocene is thus a potentially fruitful period for research.   Scott focused on benthic foraminifera in the North and South Atlantic, and their relationship to surface and deep water circulation and Antarctic ice volumes.   The major question to be addressed is: what was the ice volume in the Pliocene?  One model involves an ice volume that is two-thirds that of the present Antarctic ice sheet, while another proposes no major change in ice volume between the Pliocene and today.   Some evidence is present to suggest warmer climates during the Pliocene, such as the presence of southern Beech preserved in glacial sediments on Antarctica; there is no convincing evidence from 6180 data, however.   Scott used cluster analysis of benthic foram data from DSDP sites in the North Atlantic to evaluate bottom water conditions, and carbon isotope data to tell which water masses were dominant--southern Antarctic bottom water or North Atlantic deep water.   Increased heat transport in the North Atlantic region produced an increase in North Atlantic deep water, which affected Antarctic climate.   The difference between the Pliocene and today is that the Pliocene had reduced sea ice and no Antarctic surface water to provide moisture to the Antarctic.   Questions by Bob Ilchik and George Helz.   (20.0 minutes)

     The second talk, by Kevin Crowley of the National Research Council, was entitled "One Billion Year Thermal History of Interior North America."  Kevin examined the thermal history of the Precambrian North American shield as a method for evaluating regional epeirogeny.   The problem is that Precambrian shields, unlike our beer, are old and cold, and also dense, yet are topographically high in many areas.   Kevin investigated this problem through fission track geochronology, in order to understand the uplift history of the shields.   Fission track studies are useful because they provide information on the age, time, and temperature evolution of the sample.   Kevin used Monte Carlo processes and 6th order polynomial equations to generate random time-temperature histories, and the calculation of model ages to compare with measured ages; this process allows constraints to be placed on the thermal history of an area, and may reveal paleogeothermal gradients in some cases. Kevin studied surface samples from the Lake Superior region and discovered young Phanerozoic heating ages, from 600 to 200 million years old.   In one drill core from northwestern Iowa, fission track ages range from 935 to about 640 million years, with deeper samples yielding younger ages.   In all the samples from the Lake Superior region, a late Paleozoic to early Mesozoic thermal peak is evident, despite the Proterozoic age of the analyzed rocks.   These results suggest that the Precambrian shield of the Lake Superior region is mainly a Mesozoic to perhaps a Cenozoic feature, and that the shield originally was covered by a thick Paleozoic cover.   Kevin left us with the question: where did all of the Paleozoic cover go?  Questions by Jane Hammarstrom, Cy Galvin, Curt Lindsay, George Helz, Phil Bethke, and E-an Zen.   (20.5 minutes)

     The last talk of the evening was presented by Bill Boning of the USGS in Reston, on "The 1993 Floods in the Upper Mississippi River Basin."  While heavy rain fell outside on Florida Avenue, Bill told us about heavy rain in the Midwest this past summer.   The 1993 floods in the upper Mississippi River basin resulted in unprecedented damages, including more than $10 billion in property losses, the evacuation of more than 80,000 people, the destruction of millions of acres of crops, and widespread infrastructure disruption.   In the Midwest, the rainfall in the preceding six months was 150-200% higher than normal, producing 100-year flood levels on the Mississippi at St Louis, and even higher levels on the Raccoon River in Iowa.   The heavy rain was caused by an unusually southerly track for the jet stream during the late spring and summer, which brought unseasonably cool, dry air that mixed with warm, moist air from the Gulf of Mexico.   In contrast, rainfall in the southeastern U.S. was less than 50% of normal.   Bill showed many slides of flooding along the Mississippi and other rivers, noting that the flow on the Mississippi at St. Louis in August was above flood stage for 80 days, from late June to early September, including a flow of more than one million cubic feet per second in August.   Bill also described the effects of the flooding on agriculture chemical discharge, which were presumed to be lower because of dilution by the increased water flow.   However, in 1993 concentrations of herbicides such as Atrazine have been relatively high,  indicating a large amount of erosion of agricultural chemicals from farm fields.   The USGS response to the flooding included the taking of more than 2000 discharge measurements above the normal amount,  increased sampling for sediment and water quality at 142 locations, and continuous data provision for emergency river management.   Questions by Bob Ilchik, Dallas Peck, Jingle Ruppert, Joanne Bourgeois, Bill Houser, E-an Zen, Charles Prewitt, Blair Jones, Murray Hitzman, George Helz, and Margaret Chauncey.   (24.5 minutes)

     President Bethke adjourned the meeting at 9:50 p.m., with 77 attendees present.

     Respect fully submitted,

     John F. Slack

     Meeting Secretary

 

MINUTES OF THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

1245th Meeting, December 8,  1993

     Vice President Rosalind Helz called the meeting to order at 8:07 p.m.   Two new members were announced, James McDougall and Richard Wunderman.   Six guests were introduced, including Amelia Logan, Charlie Alpers, Graeilla Sarmiento, Susana Garcia-Lopez, Gary Reeves, and Will White.   Roz also announced the death of Gil Espenshade.

     The only talk of the evening was President Bethke's Presidential Address, entitled "Cenozoic Geomorphic Evolution, climate Change, and Supergene Alteration, Central San Juan Mountains, Colorado."  Phil described in detail the use of stable isotope and K/Ar data on supergene alunite and jarosite in the Creede mining district for constraining the evolution of Cenozoic geomorphology and climate in part of the southern Rocky Mountains.  Alunite and jarosite form during the oxidation of sulfide-bearing mineral deposits, by the interaction of silicate wall rocks with sulfuric acid produced by pyrite oxidation.   Alunite and jarosite are both hydrous, sulfate-bearing minerals that contain four stable isotope sites and abundant potassium suitable for age dating.   Phil outlined four major implications of the acquired data: 1) the sulfur isotopic composition of sulfur in the sulfate should approximate the sulfur isotopic composition of the precursor sulfide minerals; 2) the hydrogen and oxygen isotopic compositions of the OH site should be equivalent to the isotopic composition of the local meteoric water that formed the alunite and jarosite; 3) the oxygen isotopic composition of the oxygen in the sulfate yields information on the hydrologic environment of the supergene alteration; and 4) the potassium in both alunite and jarosite can be used for radiometric dating to determine the age of the supergene alteration.   Two equations were shown for pyrite oxidation,  one air-dominant and the other water-dominant.   Combined d180 and d34S data can be used to evaluate air- versus water-dominant oxidation, because air-dominant oxidation yields heavy d180 values, whereas water-dominant oxidation yields light d180 values.   After reviewing general aspects of the geology and geomorphology of the San Juan Mountains, Phil showed plots of stable isotope data for Creede alunites and jarosites, and their K/Ar ages.   These data suggest that the alunite formed 4-5 million years ago in a wet environment at or below the water table, whereas jarosite formed later in an alternating wet-dry environment in the vadose zone. Geomorphically, development of a hanging topography in the region appears related to the 4- to 5 million-year-old paleo-water table that underlay it by about 500 feet; regional uplift of the southern Rocky Mountains, about 5 million years ago, also caused rapid erosion with progressive lowering of the water table between 2.5 and 0.8 million years ago.   The regional uplift apparently resulted in the development of a cooler climate in the Creede area.   This work shows that combined K/Ar geochronology and stable isotope studies of supergene alunite and jarosite may be successfully used for evaluating climate change and establishing paleo-topography and erosion rates.

     Vice President Helz adjourned the meeting at 9:07 p.m., with 78 attendees present.

     Respectfully submitted,

     John F. Slack

     Meeting Secretary

 

GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON

Minutes of the 101st Annual Meeting December 8, 1993

     President Phil Bethke convened the 101st Annual Meeting at 9:27 p.m. Minutes of the previous regular meeting were read by Meetings Secretary John Slack, and approved.  Vice President Helz read the report of the Council Secretary, in the absence of Karen Prestegaard, and it also was approved.   Moto Sato's Treasurers Report, which indicated that the Society is in good financial shape, was read and approved.   President Bethke read the report of the Auditing Committee for absent Chairman Marcus Milling, which was also approved.   Kathy Krohn presented the report of the Membership Committee, revealing that we gained 53 new members during the year and lost 79, for a net total of 580 members, including 397 regular, 165 corresponding, and 18 student members.

     John Jens, Chairman of the Public Service Committee, reported that in 1993,  16 GSW members judged seven science fairs, and that the grand prize winner was Ellen Houseknecht from Leesburg, for her study on "The effect of sediment size of sand and gravel on permeability."   John also noted that AGI gave us a discount on books that were presented to winners of the various science fairs. One field trip was held during the year, in the fall, which was led by E-an Zen and Karen Prestegaard to potholes and other features of Great Falls.

     Bruce Lipin, Chairman of the Awards Committee, presented the GSW awards for the year.   The Bradley Award for best scientific presentation went to Alan Linde of DTM for his talk on the use of strain meters during the 1991 eruption of Hekla in Iceland. Second prize went to Andre Sher of the Russian Academy of Sciences, for his presentation on mammoth extinction in the Arctic.   Honorable mention went to Chris Newell, Sean Solomon, Jim Luhr, Bill Melson, Jim Hays, Jim Montrees, Dick Fiske, and Murray Hitzman.   The Sleeping Bear award was presented to Jim Monsees for his response to a question regarding the SSC in Texas.

     President Bethke read the names of the nominated officers and councilors of the Society for 1994, which were approved by the members.   He then turned over the Budweiser gavel and a dusty copy of Roberts Rules of Order to new President Rosalind Helz.  She read the names of Steve Shirey and Jane Hammarstrom, the Program Cochairs for 1994, and adjourned the meeting at 10:15 p.m.  Attendance was 78.

     Respectfully Submitted,

     John Slack

     Meeting Secretary